Senators Collins, Lieberman Cite DHS Progress, But More Work Needs to be Done

Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committee Chairman Joe Lieberman, ID-Conn., and Ranking Member Susan Collins, R-Me., Thursday, armed with a new status report on the Department of Homeland Security, said the Department has made progress in achieving some of its mission goals since it was established in early 2003 but has faltered in achieving others.

The new report by the Government Accountability Office (GAO) entitled “DHS: Progress Report on Implementation of Mission and Management Functions” found that while significant progress has been made to improve maritime security and moderate progress has been made in areas such as aviation security and critical infrastructure protection, overall DHS has failed to achieve a comprehensive strategy for an agency wide transformation. It found that the Department has not adequately involved the private sector in preventing potential attacks and its emergency preparedness and response capabilities are not yet sufficient for responding to man-made or natural disasters.

Senator Collins said, “That DHS should be a work in progress after only four years should be a surprise to no one. It is however, disturbing to see “limited progress” in four areas as critical as human-capitol management, information technology management, science and technology, and emergency preparedness and response. I am pleased that the report cites significant progress in the area of maritime security since our Committee has worked very hard on that issue. But nearly six years after September 11, 2001, four years after its creation, and two years after Hurricane Katrina, the Department must pick up the pace of its progress. GAOs report should serve as a roadmap in this effort. With so much at stake and so many areas where progress is still required, America cannot settle for a mixed report card.”

“The report confirms what many of us have believed,” Senator Lieberman said. “First, that the Department has made important progress establishing programs and procedures that make us safer today than we were before the September 11 attacks. And, second, that there are also serious deficiencies at the Department that require more focused attention and resources than they have received to date.”

GAO praised the Department’s efforts to improve aviation security, noting that DHS achieved 17 of the 24 performance expectations GAO identified in this area. The Department had moderate success in protecting the nation’s critical infrastructure, achieving four out of the seven GAO-identified expectations. For emergency preparedness, however, DHS failed to meet 18 of 24 expectations, achieving little or no success. The Department’s science and technology initiatives failed to achieve success in five of the six performance goals identified by GAO.